Comparative Modal Analysis of Engineering Materials for High-Speed Machining Applications Using CATIA
1Research Scholar Pawan Sawle, 2Professor Ghanshyam Dhanera
Department of Mechanical Engineering, BM College of Technology Indore
Abstract- The present research investigates the comparative modal analysis of three different engineering materials - AISI 4140 alloy steel, Ti-6Al-4V titanium alloy, and carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) - using CATIA software. The study focuses on analyzing and comparing the dynamic characteristics including natural frequencies, modal stress distributions, and displacement patterns for the first ten modes of vibration in critical machine tool components. The analysis was performed on standardized test specimens with identical geometric configurations to establish a direct comparison of material-dependent behavioral patterns in high-speed machining applications. The results demonstrate that Ti-6Al-4V exhibits the highest natural frequencies ranging from 195.823 Hz to 5124.67 Hz across the ten modes, followed by AISI 4140 (171.797 Hz to 4924.49 Hz) and CFRP (98.432 Hz to 2841.31 Hz). The stress analysis reveals maximum values of 1.48E+12 N/m², 1.22E+12 N/m², and
7.14E+10 N/m² for Ti-6Al-4V, AISI 4140, and CFRP respectively at the tenth mode. Displacement patterns indicate that CFRP experiences the highest deflection (890-1240 mm), while Ti-6Al-4V demonstrates the most restricted displacement (312-587 mm). The research provides valuable insights into the dynamic behavior of these materials, facilitating informed material selection for various manufacturing applications and tooling designs. The findings particularly highlight the potential of CFRP as a lightweight alternative in applications where vibration damping and lower stress concentrations are desired. Utilizing CATIA for the component modeling and frequency analysis has enabled precise simulations and detailed insights into the material-specific behaviors under dynamic machining conditions. The findings provide essential data that could influence material selection in modern manufacturing processes. This research contributes to the field by offering a deeper understanding of how material properties affect the dynamic performance of manufacturing components, guiding production engineers in optimizing designs for precision and efficiency in various machining applications.
Index Terms- AISI 4140, Ti-6Al-4V, CFRP, CATIA modeling, frequency/modal analysis, displacement analysis, stress analysis, manufacturing components, high-speed machining.
